Side A
1. Muppet Show Theme Song — Performed by OK Go
2. Rainbow Connection — Performed by Weezer ft. Hayley Williams
3. Mahna Mahna — Performed by The Fray
4. Movin' Right Along — Performed by Alkaline Trio
5. Our World — Performed by My Morning Jacket
6. Halfway Down the Stairs — Performed by Amy Lee

Side B
1. Mr. Bassman — Performed by Sondre Lerche
2. Wishing Song — Performed by The Airborne Toxic Event
3. Night Life — Performed by Brandon Saller and Billy Martin
4. Bein' Green — Performed by Andrew Bird
5. I Hope That Something Better Comes Along — Performed by Matt Nathanson
6. I'm Going to Go Back There Someday — Performed by Rachael Yamagata